To Many Choices

I am in desperate need to re paint the kitchen. I can no longer live with the "torchlight" yellow. We have 4 different colors up on the wall as test swatches. So far the only one I like is the one from Colin's room. Would it be weird to have the same paint color in the kitchen?

I wanted gray but I have decided I should avoid it unless I am okay with it looking somewhat blue.  We are planning on painting the cabinets white before the end of summer, I do love the white on white but I don't think my husband was in favor of it. Here is what I have narrowed it down to:

I would like to paint it before Colin's 2nd Birthday. So the deadline is March 29th. I need help choosing a color, and fast. Brett doesn't want to help choose a color after the paint fiasco in the bathroom :)